Pizza
Regular Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$29.95
Original Pizza
$31.99
Ala Vodka Pizza
Mozzarella in vodka sauce.
$34.00
Bianca Pizza
Mozzarella, parmesan, ricotta, and a touch of garlic (no sauce).
$34.00
Fresh Mozzarella Pizza
$34.00
Spinach Tomato Pizza
Roasted tomatoes and fresh spinach with a touch of garlic.
$34.00
Margarita Pizza
Mozzarella, fresh tomato sauce, and basil.
$34.00
Mushroom Pizza
Wild mushrooms topped with roasted garlic and three cheeses.
$34.00
Pepper Pizza
Mixed peppers and onions and tomato sauce.
$34.00
Pasta Pizza
Vodka sauce and cheese on pasta.
$39.00
Cheeseless Vegetable Pizza
Mixed peppers, roasted tomatoes, and fresh tomato sauce.
$33.00
Grandma Pizza
Mixed mozzarella, tomato sauce topped with parmesan.
$34.00
Sicilian Pizza
$34.00
Deep Dish Pizza
Thick dough with tomato sauce topped with mozzarella.
$34.00
Tomato Basil Deep Dish
Roasted tomatoes, mozzarella, and fresh basil.
$34.00
Stuffed Crust Pizza
Crust stuffed with cheese and spread with butter and garlic.
$35.00
Whole Wheat Pie
$30.00
Green Olives Pie
$32.00
Black Olives Pie
$32.00
Eggplant Pie
$34.00
Broccoli Pie
$34.00
Vegan Pepperoni Pie
Vegan Pepperoni
$36.00
Low Carb Pizza
Regular Low Carb Pizza
$14.00
Olive & Cheese Low Carb Pizza
$15.00
Grandma Sauce Low Carb Pizza
$15.00
Fresh Spinach & Cheese Low Carb Pizza
$15.00
Mushroom Roasted Garlic with Cheese Low Carb Pizza
$15.00
Gluten Free Pizza
$18.00
Personal Pies
Vodka Pie
$17.00
Pepper Pie
$17.00
Olive Pie
$17.00
Broccoli Pie
$17.00
Mushroom Pie
$17.00
Original Pie
$17.00
Regular Pie
$16.00
Vegan Pepperoni Pie
Vegan Pepperoni
$17.00
Slices
Regular Slice
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$4.99
Original Pizza Slice
$5.50
Vegan Pepperoni Slice
Vegan Pepperoni
$5.50
Specialty Slices
Ala Vodka Pizza Slice
Mozzarella in vodka sauce.
$5.50
Bianca Pizza Slice
Mozzarella, parmesan, ricotta, and a touch of garlic (no sauce).
$5.50
Fresh Mozzarella Pizza Slice
$5.50
Cheese Crust Pizza Slice
$5.50
Spinach Tomato Pizza Slice
Roasted tomatoes and fresh spinach with a touch of garlic.
$5.50
Margarita Pizza Slice
Mozzarella, fresh tomato sauce, and basil.
$5.50
Mushroom Pizza Slice
Wild mushrooms topped with roasted garlic and three cheeses.
$5.50
Pepper Pizza Slice
Mixed peppers and onions and tomato sauce.
$5.50
Pasta Pizza Slice
Vodka sauce and cheese on pasta.
$6.50
Grandma Pizza Slice
Mixed mozzarella, tomato sauce topped with parmesan.
$5.50
Sicilian Pizza Slice
$5.00
Deep Dish Pizza Slice
Thick dough with tomato sauce topped with mozzarella.
$5.00
Tomato Basil Deep Dish Slice
Roasted tomatoes, mozzarella, and fresh basil.
$5.00
Stuffed Crust Pizza Slice
Crust stuffed with cheese and spread with butter and garlic.
$5.50
Pesto Pizza Slice
$5.50
Omelets
Sunny Side Up Omelette
Egg fried on one side.
$15.00
Cheese Omelette
Filled with melted mozzarella.
$15.00
Italian Omelette
Fresh basil, roasted tomatoes, and mozzarella.
$15.00
Marinara Omelette
Sauteed spinach and mozzarella.
$15.00
Greek Omelette
Feta cheese, olives, and onion.
$15.00
Sam’s Omelette
Sauteed spinach and feta cheese.
$15.00
Appetizers
Mozzarella Sticks
Cheese sticks with a side of marinara sauce.
$11.00
Homemade Onion Rings
$11.00
Regular Fries
$9.00
Cajun Fries
$9.00
Sweet Chili Fries
$9.50
Cheese Fries
$13.00
Gravy Fries
Melted cheese and hot gravy.
$13.00
Eggplant Rollatini
Ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan with tomato sauce.
$16.00
Stacked Eggplant Florentine
Fresh spinach, eggplant, ricotta, parmesan, and mozzarella cheese topped with tomato sauce.
$16.00
Sauteed Vegetables
$16.00
Garlic Knots
$4.00
Cheese Pretzels
$10.00
Pizza Roll
Deep-Fried crust with sauce and cheese
$8.50
Soup
Fagioli Soup
White bean, spinach, and vegetables.
$10.00
French Onion Soup
Served with bread and melted cheese.
$11.00
Lentil Soup
$10.00
Salad
Greek Salad
$16.00
Caesar Salad
$16.00
Create Own Salad
$15.00
Stromboli
Mushroom & Cheese Stromboli
$10.00
Spinach & Cheese Stromboli
$10.00
Wraps
Tuna Wrap
$13.00
Primavera Wrap
Spinach, zucchini, mushroom, tomato, and mozzarella cheese.
$13.00
Avocado Wrap
Peppers, red onion, and avocado.
$13.00
Vegetable Wrap
Zucchini, onions, peppers, mushrooms, and cheese.
$13.00
Eggplant Parmigiana Wrap
$13.00
Veggie Burger Wrap
Lettuce and tomato.
$13.00
Caprese Wrap
Roasted peppers, tomato, and mozzarella with pesto.
$13.00
Grilled Salmon Wrap
Salmon filet with sauteed spinach and honey dijon.
$18.00
Paninis
Tuna Panini
$14.00
Vegetable Panini
Peppers, zucchini, red onions, mushrooms, and mozzarella.
$14.00
Caprese Panini
Roasted peppers, tomato, mozzarella with pesto.
$14.00
Eggplant Parmigiana Panini
$14.00
Greek Panini
Feta cheese, tomatoes, olives, and pesto.
$14.00
Sam's Panini
Omelette, feta cheese, and sauteed spinach.
$14.00
Pasta
Chef’s Pasta
Fresh spinach, capers, tomatoes, and basil in white wine.
$17.00
Pasta Primavera
Broccoli, zucchini, black olives, and roasted red peppers.
$17.00
Penne Di Pomodoro Pasta
Tomatoes, fresh basil, and parmesan cheese.
$17.00
Penne Ala Funghi Pasta
Wild mushrooms in cream sauce.
$17.00
Pasta Puttanesca
Capers, black olives, and fresh basil in tomato sauce.
$17.00
Penne Ala Vodka Pasta
Cream sauce and fresh marinara.
$17.00
Eggplant Parmesan Pasta
Breaded eggplant, mozzarella cheese in tomato sauce.
$17.00
Baked Penne Pasta
Parmesan, mozzarella in tomato sauce.
$17.00
Benny’s Pasta
Sauteed artichokes, broccoli, cherry tomatoes, capers, and fresh garlic in the red sauce.
$17.00
Pasta Con Broccoli
Sauteed garlic, broccoli, and parmesan in a white wine sauce.
$17.00
Pasta Luigino
Sauteed garlic, basil, mushrooms, and roasted tomatoes.
$17.00
Alfredo Sauce Pasta
Fettuccine in cream and parmesan.
$17.00
Marinara Sauce Pasta
Fresh garlic and basil in tomato sauce.
$17.00
Pesto Pasta
Olive oil, fresh garlic, heavy cream, and pesto, and parmesan.
$17.00
Gnocchi Pasta
$19.00
Ravioli Pasta
$19.00
Fish
Grilled Salmon
$18.00
Drinks
Soda
$2.50
Snapple
$3.00
Water
$2.00
Seltzer Water
$2.50
Benny's Pizza Ave J
Looking for something good to eat? Try the best pizzas in Brooklyn. Benny's Pizza Ave J remains one of the most popular in Brooklyn thanks to its fresh offerings and classic pizzas. Give their menu a try and see what all the fuss is about. If you're feeling hungry, don't hesitate. Enjoy the top dishes Brooklyn has to offer. This restaurant is known for Regular Pizza. Try it for yourself and see what the fuss is about. Don't miss out on regular fries while ordering your pizza. It's a tasty way to bulk up your meal when you're extra hungry. This reliable restaurant has been a Slice partner for 6 years. You can count on them providing something tasty. Benny's Pizza Ave J accepts credit cards. That makes it easy to get your pizza sooner.
Full Hours